Contestant Az-ai/glm-5.3
Contestant A · preserved capture
Score—
Wall time7:33
HTML start—
Cost$0.0707
glm-5.3 and gemini-3.7-flash: an incomplete Orbit Radio run
One model produced a reviewable artifact and the other did not. Proofrun preserves the artifact assessment and the failure record without declaring an automatic head-to-head winner.
Bounded resultOne reviewable artifact was preserved. No automatic winner was assigned.Structured from the locked human evaluation. One run; no broader ranking is implied.
OutcomeIncomplete comparison
WinnerNot assigned
Scores—:11
EvidenceAttempt lineage preserved
The result,
shown before explained.
Contestant Bgoogle/gemini-3.7-flash
Contestant B · preserved capture
Score11
Wall time0:44
HTML start0:14
Cost$0.0599
“Hard to review this incomplete artifact, barely anything to interact with, from what I can see the UI is okay but uninspired.”Locked before model reveal
Requirements first.
Weighted quality second.
Frozen requirements6 judgments per artifact
| Requirement | A | B |
|---|---|---|
| The central dial responds to turning or dragging. | Unscored | Missed |
| Five distinct fictional stations are available. | Unscored | Missed |
| Station name, frequency, color, and visualization change together. | Unscored | Missed |
| Previous and next controls work consistently. | Unscored | Missed |
| The current station is visually unmistakable. | Unscored | Missed |
| The single-file instrument remains responsive and works offline. | Unscored | Missed |
Weighted criteriaA null / B 11
Visual design · 30%
Hierarchy, composition, typography, color, polish, and coherent visual judgment.
A / 105
B / 103
Interaction & usability · 30%
Discoverability, responsiveness, feedback, control quality, and interaction feel.
A / 105
B / 101
Technical robustness · 30%
Runtime correctness, edge-case handling, performance, responsiveness, and code reliability.
A / 105
B / 101
Originality · 10%
Useful creative choices that go beyond a generic first solution without harming clarity.
A / 105
B / 105
The claim, with its
conditions attached.
Immutable attempts and publication recordInspect provenance
This Results Brief is rendered from a sanitized, allowlisted record rather than AI-authored article prose. Credentials, raw responses, generated source, executable artifacts, and private reviewer notes remain in the private Studio.
Run recordPR-MT1I9RG1-80
Outcomeincomplete comparison
Test lineagev3 · curated:orbit-radio:v3
Identityrevealed
Evaluationlocked
Record hashsha256:dd2bccfa455de50682e34b0024f6dda1997ebc131586150077b31b674120104e
Immutable attempt ledger
Download the hashed publication record ↓A #1 original: invalid or non reviewable artifact (token ceiling, Z.AI) · B #1 original: truncated submission (token ceiling, Google AI Studio)